New
BDSM
Jewelry & Day Collars
LGBTQ+ Shop
Spicy Toys
Pain Play
Clothing
Accessories
Gifts

Butt Stuff

Restrained Grace is the only place you'll find rose gold butt plugs and iridescent rainbow butt plugs! Our anal plugs feature sparkling crystals and stunning, vibrant finishes, available in small, medium, or large. Start small for beginners, or buy a whole set for anal training.
Sort by:
Nexus Anal Beginner Kit
Nexus

Nexus Anal Beginner Kit

$65.00
(0)
Tailz - Tailz Snap-On Interchangeable Black Bunny Tail
Tailz

Tailz - Tailz Snap-On Interchangeable Black Bunny Tail

$22.00
(0)
CalExotics - Lube Tube Applicator in Fuchsia
CalExotics

CalExotics - Lube Tube Applicator in Fuchsia

$12.00
(0)
Silver Butt Plug - Rainbow Crystal Rhinestone Princess Plug in 3 sizes
Restrained Grace

Silver Butt Plug - Rainbow Crystal Rhinestone Princess Plug in 3 sizes

$12.00 – $16.00
(2)
Medium, Large
Medium, Large
Gold Butt Plug - Rainbow Crystal Rhinestone Princess Plug Available in 3 sizes
Restrained Grace

Gold Butt Plug - Rainbow Crystal Rhinestone Princess Plug Available in 3 sizes

$12.00 – $16.00
(0)
Small, Medium, Large
Small, Medium, Large
Avant - Avant Genderqueer Pride Plug
Avant

Avant - Avant Genderqueer Pride Plug

$45.00
(0)
Avant - Avant Asexual Pride Plug
Avant

Avant - Avant Asexual Pride Plug

$45.00
(0)
Avant - Avant Pride Power Play Plug
Avant

Avant - Avant Pride Power Play Plug

$45.00
(0)
CalExotics Toys Dr. Joel Premium Prostate Massager
CalExotics

CalExotics - Dr. Joel Premium Prostate Massager

$20.00
(0)
Satisfyer Toys Satisfyer Plugs Silicone 3 Piece Set
Satisfyer

Satisfyer - Satisfyer Booty Call Plugs (Silicone 3 Piece Set)

$28.00
(0)
Tailz - Tailz Snap-On Interchangeable Black & White Fox Tail
Tailz

Tailz - Tailz Snap-On Interchangeable Black & White Fox Tail

$34.00
(0)
ns novelties - Firefly Pleasure Plugs Trainer Kit
ns novelties

ns novelties - Firefly Pleasure Plugs Trainer Kit

$42.00
(0)
CalExotics Toys Boundless Smooth Probe - 7"/17.75cm
CalExotics

CalExotics - Boundless Smooth Probe - 7"/17.75cm

$32.00
(0)
Blush - Luxe Beginner Silicone Butt Plug Kit in Pink
Blush

Blush - Luxe Beginner Silicone Butt Plug Kit in Pink

$45.00
(0)
Rose Gold Butt Plug - Rainbow Crystal Rhinestone
Restrained Grace

Rose Gold Butt Plug - Rainbow Crystal Rhinestone

$20.00
(0)
Rainbow Butt Plug - Rainbow Crystal Rhinestone Available in Two Sizes
Restrained Grace

Rainbow Butt Plug - Rainbow Crystal Rhinestone Available in Two Sizes

$18.00 – $20.00
(0)
Savvy - Bump Rechargeable Anal Vibe in Deep Purple
Savvy

Savvy - Bump Rechargeable Anal Vibe in Deep Purple

$58.00$46.00
(0)
ns novelties - Firefly Small Prince Butt Plug in Glowing Pink
ns novelties

ns novelties - Firefly Small Prince Butt Plug in Glowing Pink

$16.00
(0)
Restrained Grace Plug Rose Gold Butt Plug - Crystal Rhinestone Princess Plug in 3 sizes
Restrained Grace

Rose Gold Butt Plug - Crystal Rhinestone Princess Plug Available in 3 sizes

$12.00 – $16.00
(11)